It's Chrismas time. And God is more prevalent than any other time of the year. Many homes put up nativity scenes, showing Mary and Joseph around a crib with a baby Jesus, and some have Wise Men and maybe animals to complete the scene.
A local church has an event, open to everyone, of a Bethlehem, including Roman soldiers, a census taker, two inns, a stable (or manger) and animals such as sheep, a donkey, and camels. They tell the story of Jesus birth and finish with beautiful Christmas music.
Christmas music is heard most everywhere, in stores and on the radio.
Is this a problem? Should any or all of these be eliminated or 'outlawed'. Of course not. These are all done by people and businesses and not mandated by government.
Now look out at the street and look at the ad on the bus going by. It says "Millions of Americans are Good without God." Are you offended? Perhaps. Does the ad stay on the bus? Of course.
The Metroplex Atheists of Dallas-Fort Worth placed the ads because "we want to tell people they are not alone." During Christmas time, many people feel alone or alienated because they don't have someone to share the 'holiday spirit' with. The Metroplex Atheists are reaching out to people. "It can be pretty lonely for a nonbeliever at Christmas time around here," says Mr McDonald, chairman of a local Atheist group.
Some religious groups have tried to boycott the buses or get the bus line to stop advertising any religious ads. But all ads are welcome (excluding tobacco and alcohol). As they should be.
Mr Edwords, national directory of the United Coalition of Reason says of the money spent on the ads, "That's more brouhaha for the buck than we have seen anywhere." Which only incites more anger from religious groups.
Both sides need to relax, take a deep breath, and go about their business. Both sides can advertise to their hearts content, and talk to people, and keep everything on a positive level.
Peace. What a concept.
----------
Atheist Ads on Buses Rattle Fort Worth (New York Times)
While I agree with the sentiment, the New York billboard, featuring a nativity scene, is over the line. For the Holidays, an Atheism Billboard (New York Times) This one is part of a 'war on Christmas'. Nothing good will come of it.
Showing posts with label Freedoms. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Freedoms. Show all posts
Wednesday, December 15, 2010
Thursday, November 18, 2010
Playing chess in the park? Must bring a child with you.
Police have issued summonses to chess players who are 'unaccompanies by minors' in New York public playgrounds. The playgrounds have signs that say adults must be accompanied or they cannot be in the play area. Chess players are incensed, saying "What is so harmful with chess?"
While chess isn't really the issue, the intent of the law is plain: the playground is designed for children and 'unaccompanied adults' are not welcome.
‘Police! Step Away From the Chess Table’ (New York Times)
While I feel for the chess players, if they want to play, they can find another area or get the law changed. And the police cannot make exceptions. Allowing one group and not another would not be a fair way of dealing with the issue.
In the meantime, the chess players are required to go to court before the end of the year where they may pay a $50 fine. Nothing is listed in the article, but I would think that they would be given a warning before any summonses are issued since this is a minor infraction by anyone's measure.
While chess isn't really the issue, the intent of the law is plain: the playground is designed for children and 'unaccompanied adults' are not welcome.
‘Police! Step Away From the Chess Table’ (New York Times)
While I feel for the chess players, if they want to play, they can find another area or get the law changed. And the police cannot make exceptions. Allowing one group and not another would not be a fair way of dealing with the issue.
In the meantime, the chess players are required to go to court before the end of the year where they may pay a $50 fine. Nothing is listed in the article, but I would think that they would be given a warning before any summonses are issued since this is a minor infraction by anyone's measure.
Wednesday, November 10, 2010
Is that abstract art or a diseased lung?
No later than Oct 22, 2012, all cigarette packages must carry a new graphic on their packaging and in advertising. The graphics will be of such things as a person smoking with smoke coming out of a hole in their throat or a corpse with their chest stitched up. These new warnings will help "in protecting our children and the health of the American public.” (HHS)
It's not enough that we have education in schools telling children the dangers. It's not enough that we have a Sin Tax on cigarettes to dissuade people from smoking. It's not enough that there are currently warnings on cigarette packages stating things like "Smoking Causes Lung Cancer, Heart Disease, Emphysema, And May Complicate Pregnancy."
Just one more step down the path of a police state. Someone doesn't like that you do something they deem offensive, so they do everything legal to get you to stop. What is the next one? Photos of auto accidents on alcohol containers? Cheese packages with photos of clogged arteries?
If people don't know that smoking is bad for you already, looking at a picture of a dying patient won't stop them from picking up the filthy stuff. They smoke because they want to smoke or because they are addicted. If they are addicted, and want to stop, they can seek help. There are plenty of programs around to help smokers quit the disgusting habit (CDC).
Update: Last night as I was reading an Entertainment Weekly magazine, I came across an ad for USA Gold cigarettes (tagline: Your Spirit. Your Smoke.). How many children and teenagers will see the forthcoming ads with graphic depictions of dying and dead people? Is this something you want your child to see? These won't be 'movie corpses'. These are real people.
Cigarette Packages in U.S. to Carry Images of Dead Bodies, Diseased Lungs (Bloomberg)
Proposed Cigarette Product Warning Labels (FDA)
Lots of good comments here: Cigarette Warnings Go Gruesome: Did the Health Police Go Too Far?
Previous post on Sin Tax
Update: I did not realize other countries have photos on their cigarette packaging already. Cigarette Warning Labels: Brazil's More Shocking than Ours (CBSNews)
It's not enough that we have education in schools telling children the dangers. It's not enough that we have a Sin Tax on cigarettes to dissuade people from smoking. It's not enough that there are currently warnings on cigarette packages stating things like "Smoking Causes Lung Cancer, Heart Disease, Emphysema, And May Complicate Pregnancy."Yes, smoking is dumb. Yes, smoking makes your breath and clothes smell awful. Yes, smoking kills people. But as long as these adults are smoking of their own accord and it doesn't affect others, including children, there should be no laws or taxes to prevent or dissuade them from doing so.
Just one more step down the path of a police state. Someone doesn't like that you do something they deem offensive, so they do everything legal to get you to stop. What is the next one? Photos of auto accidents on alcohol containers? Cheese packages with photos of clogged arteries?
If people don't know that smoking is bad for you already, looking at a picture of a dying patient won't stop them from picking up the filthy stuff. They smoke because they want to smoke or because they are addicted. If they are addicted, and want to stop, they can seek help. There are plenty of programs around to help smokers quit the disgusting habit (CDC).
Update: Last night as I was reading an Entertainment Weekly magazine, I came across an ad for USA Gold cigarettes (tagline: Your Spirit. Your Smoke.). How many children and teenagers will see the forthcoming ads with graphic depictions of dying and dead people? Is this something you want your child to see? These won't be 'movie corpses'. These are real people.
Cigarette Packages in U.S. to Carry Images of Dead Bodies, Diseased Lungs (Bloomberg)
Proposed Cigarette Product Warning Labels (FDA)
Lots of good comments here: Cigarette Warnings Go Gruesome: Did the Health Police Go Too Far?
Previous post on Sin Tax
Update: I did not realize other countries have photos on their cigarette packaging already. Cigarette Warning Labels: Brazil's More Shocking than Ours (CBSNews)
Wednesday, October 27, 2010
Citizenship Test
The link below are questions for becoming a Citizen of the United States. There are 96 questions. See how many you can answer correctly.
U.S. Citizenship Test (Christian Science Monitor)
Most of the questions are good, knowing about the Constitution, Bill of Rights, and branches of Federal government. I'm not sure about the geography questions. Which state borders Mexico? Which ocean is off the East Coast of the United States? But these are quibbles.
How many questions did you get correct? I'm curious how many people know the answer for Benjamin Franklin. And if most Americans know who is next in line for the Presidency if the President and Vice-President are no long qualified. The answer to that last one might scare some people.
I was able to correctly answer 95% correctly. I missed questions 69, 34, 27, 23, and 3. I'm disappointed I didn't answer correctly the question: "Why did the Colonists fight the British?"
Knowing the answers to all of the questions won't make someone a better citizen or get them involved in local politics. But I'm wondering why the passing percentage is 60%? This means that a 'new Citizen' could have missed up to 38 questions. Canada also has a passing percentage of 60%, but they only have 20 questions which means you can miss only 8 (Canadian Citizenship Test - A Brief Overview). Britain has a passing percentage of 75% (U.K. Citizenship Test: Too hard for most Britains).
The current U.S. test was first used in 2008. Immigration Officials Unveil Redesigned U.S. Citizenship Test
U.S. Citizenship Test (Christian Science Monitor)
Most of the questions are good, knowing about the Constitution, Bill of Rights, and branches of Federal government. I'm not sure about the geography questions. Which state borders Mexico? Which ocean is off the East Coast of the United States? But these are quibbles.
How many questions did you get correct? I'm curious how many people know the answer for Benjamin Franklin. And if most Americans know who is next in line for the Presidency if the President and Vice-President are no long qualified. The answer to that last one might scare some people.
I was able to correctly answer 95% correctly. I missed questions 69, 34, 27, 23, and 3. I'm disappointed I didn't answer correctly the question: "Why did the Colonists fight the British?"
Knowing the answers to all of the questions won't make someone a better citizen or get them involved in local politics. But I'm wondering why the passing percentage is 60%? This means that a 'new Citizen' could have missed up to 38 questions. Canada also has a passing percentage of 60%, but they only have 20 questions which means you can miss only 8 (Canadian Citizenship Test - A Brief Overview). Britain has a passing percentage of 75% (U.K. Citizenship Test: Too hard for most Britains).
The current U.S. test was first used in 2008. Immigration Officials Unveil Redesigned U.S. Citizenship Test
Wednesday, October 13, 2010
Free Speech rights at funerals comes to U.S. Supreme Court
Fred Phelps, who has a church with about 75 members, mostly his family, protest at funerals. Really? Are they protesting the way the funeral is held? Or the funeral company? Or an individual?
No, they protest because the federal government (and America in general) embraces gays. And gays are bad. And God is killing American soldiers because he's upset about the gay embracing.
They also protest at music concerts, sporting events and even a Holocaust Museum. Reprehensible as their proclamations and signs are ("Fags Doom Nations") they have a right to Free Speech under the First Amendment.
As disgusting and anti-Christian as they are (God DOES love everyone), someone has died. Whether you like or dislike the person, their attitudes, or actions, they have died. Their family should be allowed respect to bury them; without anyone disturbing them.
Phelps and his religious family are smart about it, though. They don't protest right next to the funeral. They are some distance away. They don't target any individual person (dead or alive). They protest generically, holding up signs and chanting things such as "God Hates Fags"; and "God Bless IEDs".
This case isn't about simply protesting at a funeral, it is specifically about speech directed at an individual, in this case, the soldier's father.
Having said all of this, I know the U.S. Supreme Court will fall on the side of Free Speech, as they should. Fred Phelps and his followers will probably be allowed to continue their homophobic hate speech. And gay soldiers will continue to die for our freedoms. And America will embrace gays more and more over the years, just as they did with Civil Rights and Women's Rights.
Maybe Fred Phelps will pass soon, and his followers will disperse, with no one taking the reigns. Then there will be no more media coverage of this loony-toon. One can only hope.
US weighs rights for anti-gay church (The Age)
Here is a good article on Fred Phelps and his beliefs: Fred Phelps and Goodness (InSearchOfGoodness)
Even the hatefulness of Fred Phelps is protected by this country’s free speech (KansasCity.com)
No, they protest because the federal government (and America in general) embraces gays. And gays are bad. And God is killing American soldiers because he's upset about the gay embracing.
They also protest at music concerts, sporting events and even a Holocaust Museum. Reprehensible as their proclamations and signs are ("Fags Doom Nations") they have a right to Free Speech under the First Amendment.
As disgusting and anti-Christian as they are (God DOES love everyone), someone has died. Whether you like or dislike the person, their attitudes, or actions, they have died. Their family should be allowed respect to bury them; without anyone disturbing them.
Phelps and his religious family are smart about it, though. They don't protest right next to the funeral. They are some distance away. They don't target any individual person (dead or alive). They protest generically, holding up signs and chanting things such as "God Hates Fags"; and "God Bless IEDs".
This case isn't about simply protesting at a funeral, it is specifically about speech directed at an individual, in this case, the soldier's father.
Having said all of this, I know the U.S. Supreme Court will fall on the side of Free Speech, as they should. Fred Phelps and his followers will probably be allowed to continue their homophobic hate speech. And gay soldiers will continue to die for our freedoms. And America will embrace gays more and more over the years, just as they did with Civil Rights and Women's Rights.
Maybe Fred Phelps will pass soon, and his followers will disperse, with no one taking the reigns. Then there will be no more media coverage of this loony-toon. One can only hope.
US weighs rights for anti-gay church (The Age)
Here is a good article on Fred Phelps and his beliefs: Fred Phelps and Goodness (InSearchOfGoodness)
Even the hatefulness of Fred Phelps is protected by this country’s free speech (KansasCity.com)
Labels:
Ethics,
Freedoms,
Government,
Law,
Media,
Privacy,
Religion,
Society,
Supreme Court
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
Executive pay is too high? Maybe.
How much money is 'enough' for a corporate executive? And for purposes of this post, let's leave the 50-person company out and talk only about the Fortune 500 companies.
For 2010, the top 4 companies in regards to revenue are Wal-Mart, Exxon Mobil, Chevron, and General Electric.
How much profit did these companies make for the previous year?
The new financial reform going thru Congress has a requirement that companies disclose the ratio between CEO compensation and the typical employee's pay.
The average worker made these amounts at the four top Fortune 500 companies:
So the ratio of CEO compensation to average employee salary would be:
Wal-Mart - 655
Exxon Mobil - 386
Chevron - 246
General Electric - 142
Does this really tell us anything? CEO compensation is known. Average employee salary is known. This 'ratio requirement' will tell us nothing. If shareholders don't like their CEO salary, they can bring it up at the annual company meeting or some other way to get other shareholders to share their view.
People complain, at times, that firefighters and police officers are paid very little compared to what they do and CEOs are exhorbitantly paid compared to what they do. If this were a socialist society, something would be done, by the government, to 'correct these wrongs'. But since this is a capitalist society, pay is determined by supply and demand, and city budgets, and company revenues and profits. The government has no part in determining what CEO salaries should be and adding a requirement to disclose the 'compensation/salary ratio' is just some hand-waving to make people feel bitter against the CEOs with a false measure.
The Real Say on Pay (New York Times)
For 2010, the top 4 companies in regards to revenue are Wal-Mart, Exxon Mobil, Chevron, and General Electric.Their CEOs made (rounding off the numbers):
- Wal-Mart - $19 Million
- Exxon Mobil - $27 Million
- Chevron - $17 Million
- General Electric - $10 Million
How much profit did these companies make for the previous year?
- Wal-Mart grew 7%.
- Exxon Mobil dropped 57%.
- Chevron dropped 56%.
- General dropped 37%.
The new financial reform going thru Congress has a requirement that companies disclose the ratio between CEO compensation and the typical employee's pay.
The average worker made these amounts at the four top Fortune 500 companies:
- Wal-Mart - $29,000
- Exxon Mobil - $70,000
- Chevron - $69,000
- General Electric - $71,000
So the ratio of CEO compensation to average employee salary would be:
Wal-Mart - 655
Exxon Mobil - 386
Chevron - 246
General Electric - 142
Does this really tell us anything? CEO compensation is known. Average employee salary is known. This 'ratio requirement' will tell us nothing. If shareholders don't like their CEO salary, they can bring it up at the annual company meeting or some other way to get other shareholders to share their view.
People complain, at times, that firefighters and police officers are paid very little compared to what they do and CEOs are exhorbitantly paid compared to what they do. If this were a socialist society, something would be done, by the government, to 'correct these wrongs'. But since this is a capitalist society, pay is determined by supply and demand, and city budgets, and company revenues and profits. The government has no part in determining what CEO salaries should be and adding a requirement to disclose the 'compensation/salary ratio' is just some hand-waving to make people feel bitter against the CEOs with a false measure.
The Real Say on Pay (New York Times)
Monday, September 20, 2010
Smoking? Not on my beach.
New York Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg is proposing to ban smoking at New York beaches, parks, outdoor malls, and plazas. Back in 2002, he has successfully banned smoking in restaurants and bars.
Indoor smoking bans are obvious, everyone is trapped with the smoke. Outdoor smoking bans are a bit trickier. The smoke isn't trapped and disappates more quickly. But according to some studies, the smoke outdoors is still unhealthy for people nearby.
Study: Outdoor smoke gets in your lungs (USA Today)
Yes, while you can move upwind from the smoker or farther away, non-smokers shouldn't have to do so. If you are enjoying your book at a park bench, having a smoker sit next to you, or even just waking past, is distracting, obnoxious, and unhealthy. The smoke still travels and is easily enhaled by non-smokers.
I have heard arguments about music can be played too loud and should also be banned. While I haven't checked all municipalities in the U.S., I know there are 'noise pollution' laws around the country that prevent people from playing their music so loud it disturbs others within certain distances. And a big difference is that music isn't harmful to your health while smoke is.
Another argument is that barbeques and campfires do the same thing that smoke from a cigarette does. But I don't recall the last time I was even mildly annoyed with barbeque smoke or campfire smoke from someone else. If this was prevalent, I could see the same type of ban being put into place.
Lastly, walking around the beach, with cigarettes littering the area is unsightly, annoying, and a health hazard (think babies putting cigarette butts into their mouths) and I am all for a ban at the beach.
Original article:
City Wants a Smoking Ban on Beaches (New York Times)
Update:
When Citizens (Gasp) Are the Smoking Police (New York Times)
Indoor smoking bans are obvious, everyone is trapped with the smoke. Outdoor smoking bans are a bit trickier. The smoke isn't trapped and disappates more quickly. But according to some studies, the smoke outdoors is still unhealthy for people nearby.
Study: Outdoor smoke gets in your lungs (USA Today)
Yes, while you can move upwind from the smoker or farther away, non-smokers shouldn't have to do so. If you are enjoying your book at a park bench, having a smoker sit next to you, or even just waking past, is distracting, obnoxious, and unhealthy. The smoke still travels and is easily enhaled by non-smokers.
I have heard arguments about music can be played too loud and should also be banned. While I haven't checked all municipalities in the U.S., I know there are 'noise pollution' laws around the country that prevent people from playing their music so loud it disturbs others within certain distances. And a big difference is that music isn't harmful to your health while smoke is.
Another argument is that barbeques and campfires do the same thing that smoke from a cigarette does. But I don't recall the last time I was even mildly annoyed with barbeque smoke or campfire smoke from someone else. If this was prevalent, I could see the same type of ban being put into place.
Lastly, walking around the beach, with cigarettes littering the area is unsightly, annoying, and a health hazard (think babies putting cigarette butts into their mouths) and I am all for a ban at the beach.
Original article:
City Wants a Smoking Ban on Beaches (New York Times)
Update:
When Citizens (Gasp) Are the Smoking Police (New York Times)
Monday, August 30, 2010
Government has no part in who counselors can and cannot counsel.
I agree with this opinion piece that the government does not have a say in what a person can and can't study because the student won't apply the degree the way the schools wants them to.
Julea Ward was studying for her Masters in Counseling. When the school found out she refused to counsel homosexuals, because of her religous beliefs, they expelled her.
As the article states, it would be impossible to expect all counselors to counsel everyone in all situations. Sometimes their biases are so strong that they would be unable to give proper counseling for the patient.
An Attack on Religion and Counseling (NewsBlaze)
Julea Ward was studying for her Masters in Counseling. When the school found out she refused to counsel homosexuals, because of her religous beliefs, they expelled her.
As the article states, it would be impossible to expect all counselors to counsel everyone in all situations. Sometimes their biases are so strong that they would be unable to give proper counseling for the patient.
An Attack on Religion and Counseling (NewsBlaze)
Wednesday, August 18, 2010
Do you have 'privacy' for personal messages when using company phone or computer?
Imagine three scenarios:
1) You use your cell phone at work.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
2) You are using your company cell phone at work.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
3) You are using your company cell phone at home.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
If you were never told of the company policy about cell phones, should you get in trouble for any of these? Using your own phone at work, to make or receive a short text is not an issue. And as long as you didn't use the company cell phone excessively, there probably wouldn't be an issue. You send and receive a couple of text messages a day, no one cares.
Now, what if you were told the company policy. And the policy states you cannot use the company cell phone for personal business. Again, as long as you don't abuse the privilege, probably no one will care.
Now, you've been told the company policy stating you can use the cell phone for personal calls and text on your own time, but you need to pay for it. Then there is no issue if you text during your off hours. If you use it for personal calls and texts during business, you could, and should, get in trouble.
Lastly, you've been told you can use the company cell phone for personal calls and text during your off hours, but during your off hours, you send sexually explicit texts to your spouse. Now what? You are using it as instructed, you are paying to use it, should the company care what type of messages you are sending?
If you are using a company phone, don't expect to have everything you text as private. It is there phone. Even if you are paying for the texting you do during your off hours, it is their phone and the expectation should be that they will be monitoring communications.
Here is a news item before the ruling: Justices hear case of Ontario police officer who sent risque messages (LA Times)
And here is a news item on the ruling: Supreme Court allows reasonable searches of private texts on work-issued devices (Jurist.org)
1) You use your cell phone at work.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
2) You are using your company cell phone at work.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
3) You are using your company cell phone at home.
You send a text message to your spouse.
Your spouse sends a text message to you.
If you were never told of the company policy about cell phones, should you get in trouble for any of these? Using your own phone at work, to make or receive a short text is not an issue. And as long as you didn't use the company cell phone excessively, there probably wouldn't be an issue. You send and receive a couple of text messages a day, no one cares.
Now, what if you were told the company policy. And the policy states you cannot use the company cell phone for personal business. Again, as long as you don't abuse the privilege, probably no one will care.
Now, you've been told the company policy stating you can use the cell phone for personal calls and text on your own time, but you need to pay for it. Then there is no issue if you text during your off hours. If you use it for personal calls and texts during business, you could, and should, get in trouble.
Lastly, you've been told you can use the company cell phone for personal calls and text during your off hours, but during your off hours, you send sexually explicit texts to your spouse. Now what? You are using it as instructed, you are paying to use it, should the company care what type of messages you are sending?
If you are using a company phone, don't expect to have everything you text as private. It is there phone. Even if you are paying for the texting you do during your off hours, it is their phone and the expectation should be that they will be monitoring communications.
Here is a news item before the ruling: Justices hear case of Ontario police officer who sent risque messages (LA Times)
And here is a news item on the ruling: Supreme Court allows reasonable searches of private texts on work-issued devices (Jurist.org)
Monday, August 16, 2010
Prop 8, don't discriminate
Lots of talk going on about Proposition 8 being being struck down.
Much anger about 'the will of the people' being subverted. Some say "why can't we decide on validity of propositions before they are put on the ballot?" The simple reason is that if the Proposition doesn't pass, no time or money is wasted.
And when a Proposition passes, that's when the legality is questioned. Just because a Proposition is popular enough to pass doesn't make it legal. Many 'unpopular rights' were still 'legalized' because of the Constitution and Bill of Rights. Think Civil Rights and Women's Rights.
It's been over 40 years since Civil Rights legislation was adopted. 40 years from now, we'll be thinking the same thing about Gay Rights.
Someone on a site I have misplaced said the Government should give a Civil Union License to those who want to be together in the eyes of the Government and all of the legal implications. If they want to get married, they go to a church with all of the religious implications. Makes sense to me. Separation of Church and State.
Here is an opinion piece from the Los Angeles Times with a little background on Judge Walker, who struck down Proposition 8, and some quick info on racial discrimination in the 1960's. Proposition 8, Judge Walker, and our short memories (LA Times)
And another opinion on why Republicans shouldn't stand on the wrong side of another civil rights issue. My Fellow Conservatives: Think Carefully About Your Opposition to Gay Marriage (Fox News)
Much anger about 'the will of the people' being subverted. Some say "why can't we decide on validity of propositions before they are put on the ballot?" The simple reason is that if the Proposition doesn't pass, no time or money is wasted.
And when a Proposition passes, that's when the legality is questioned. Just because a Proposition is popular enough to pass doesn't make it legal. Many 'unpopular rights' were still 'legalized' because of the Constitution and Bill of Rights. Think Civil Rights and Women's Rights.
It's been over 40 years since Civil Rights legislation was adopted. 40 years from now, we'll be thinking the same thing about Gay Rights.
Someone on a site I have misplaced said the Government should give a Civil Union License to those who want to be together in the eyes of the Government and all of the legal implications. If they want to get married, they go to a church with all of the religious implications. Makes sense to me. Separation of Church and State.
Here is an opinion piece from the Los Angeles Times with a little background on Judge Walker, who struck down Proposition 8, and some quick info on racial discrimination in the 1960's. Proposition 8, Judge Walker, and our short memories (LA Times)
And another opinion on why Republicans shouldn't stand on the wrong side of another civil rights issue. My Fellow Conservatives: Think Carefully About Your Opposition to Gay Marriage (Fox News)
Wednesday, August 4, 2010
Home Schooled or Public Schooled?
I have two cousins who home school their children. One cousin has home schooled, I believe, five children and the other is in the process of home schooling two children. They both swear by it. I spoke briefly with them some years ago about home schooling and why they did it. In general, it was to give them a better learning enviornment than they could have in public or even private schools. They said their children could focus on learning while in school and not be distracted by many of the issues that affect public school children such as negative peer pressure, others' disinterest in school, and being taught 'objectionable' material, among others.
Home schooling is not just a free-for-all of teaching your child whatever you want. The state still has minimum requirements such as math skills, english skills, and science. And many of the home schooled children leave home schooling for public High School because they are more mature and can handle peer pressure better. They also usually score better on tests once they enter High School because they are ahead of other students.
Which brings up a point... Most home schooling is done by religious people who don't want certain subjects (such as evolution and sex education) to be taught to their child. And many Christians believe they are required to give their children a 'Christian education'.
When most people, myself included, hear about home schooling we ask "but what about getting interaction with other children? Aren't they missing out?" Home schooled children are usually part of an outside organization (4H club, Girl/Boy Scouts) or they volunteer or go on field trips and are on sports teams. They also get together with other families who home school and build lasting relationships with other children their own age.
Social Skills and Homeschooling: Myths and Facts (FamilyEducation.com)
So what about public schools? Are they really that bad?
The dropout rate for public schools, in the 2007-2008 year, was 4.1% across all states. While that percentage may sound low, that's over 600,000 students. Public School Graduates and Dropouts (U.S. Dept of Education) Dropout rates for home schooling? I couldn't find any statistics on it and I have never heard of children dropping out of home schooling.
Public schools have a lot of students. It is difficult (impossible?) to teach to the level that every student needs. Some students will be bored by the curriculum. Some are way over their heads.
Peer pressure is an issue, no matter where students go. But public schools have such a diverse population there are all kinds of personal influences. Apathy, drugs, violence contribute to a less-than-ideal learning envionment.
Not every family can afford the time and money (or lack of it since one parent will stay home) necessary to teach their children at home. Many are not capable of home-schooling their children in various subjects. But for those who can and want to do it, I can't find any reasons why it shouldn't be done. The children excel in most subjects and are socially involved.
New opinion: If families can afford the time and money to home-school their children, it is a win-win.
Friday, July 23, 2010
Does God approve of vandalism?
In 1892, Francis Bellamy wrote the Pledge of Allegiance (Wikipedia). In 1954, Dwight D. Eisenhower signed a bill which inserted 'Under God' into the Pledge.
In recent years, some peoples and organizations have objected to the inclusion of 'Under God' and have tried to have it removed to no success.
Recently, a group called the North Carolina Secular Association paid for advertising on billboards around the state simply saying "One Nation, Indivisible" showing how the original Pledge of Allegiance was written. A minister at the Trinity Baptist Church is having his own ads placed on billboards saying "One Nation, Under God".
A vandal spray-painted "Under God" on the Secular billboard. The vandal(s) should be caught and prosecuted for their crime. And if someone spraypaints a big X across "Under God" on the Religious billboard, they should also be prosecuted for their crime.
Both groups have the right to their Free Speech. If someone disagrees, they can put out their own ads. Or distribute flyers. Or go on their local radio station to disagree.
Billboard Battle in Bible-Belt (ABC News)
In recent years, some peoples and organizations have objected to the inclusion of 'Under God' and have tried to have it removed to no success.
Recently, a group called the North Carolina Secular Association paid for advertising on billboards around the state simply saying "One Nation, Indivisible" showing how the original Pledge of Allegiance was written. A minister at the Trinity Baptist Church is having his own ads placed on billboards saying "One Nation, Under God".
Both groups have the right to their Free Speech. If someone disagrees, they can put out their own ads. Or distribute flyers. Or go on their local radio station to disagree.
Billboard Battle in Bible-Belt (ABC News)
Wednesday, July 21, 2010
Marriage: One of These and One of Those?
When it comes to 'the definition of marriage' I know I won't sway anyone by giving my opinion on the matter. Those who have their mind made up on either side of the debate won't change their mind because of me. I'm not so full of myself to think that I'll say X and someone reading this will say 'Wow, never thought of that. Guess I'll change sides!'
But I will, for the record state my view. And the reason for my view is what determines many of the opinions I do hold. Simply stated, it is: if people are of legal age and aren't harming anyone else, let 'em do it.
Applying this to marriage, if a woman and a man want to get married, let 'em do it. If a woman and a woman want to get married, let 'em do it. And if a man and a man want to get married (wait for it...) let 'em do it.
All of this just means that society, moving forward, will have to figure out how to handle these 'plus-sized marriages'. Sure, a child will still have two biological parents, but if they are brought up in a large family, raised by everyone, how will we handle 'bring your father to work day?' When filling out the emergency contact card at school, will extra spaces need to be provided? Will 'Couples Retreats' need to be renamed 'Spouses Retreats'?
The possibilities are endless.
What brought this to mind lately was a judge striking down the Federal Defense of Marriage Act (Washington Post); a place the federal government has no place to be. (A future posting will discuss why the Federal Government needs to have their hands in so many issues.)
But I will, for the record state my view. And the reason for my view is what determines many of the opinions I do hold. Simply stated, it is: if people are of legal age and aren't harming anyone else, let 'em do it.
Applying this to marriage, if a woman and a man want to get married, let 'em do it. If a woman and a woman want to get married, let 'em do it. And if a man and a man want to get married (wait for it...) let 'em do it.
In addition, if two women and a man want to get married, let 'em do it. As long as everyone involved is of legal age and no one is being harmed, where is the issue? If six women and fix men want to get married? You know where I stand.
The possibilities are endless.
What brought this to mind lately was a judge striking down the Federal Defense of Marriage Act (Washington Post); a place the federal government has no place to be. (A future posting will discuss why the Federal Government needs to have their hands in so many issues.)
Monday, July 19, 2010
Let's raise taxes on sodas so less people will drink them.
This is America. As long as you aren't harming anyone, you should be able to do what you want to do. Right? If you want to wear your hair very long and never wash it, you should be able to do so. Right? If you want to eat potato chips for breakfast, lunch, and dinner, you can do that. Right? If you want to smoke two packs of cigarettes each day, that's okay. Right?
What if your neighbor does these things? Long hair? No problem. Eat potato chips? No problem. Smoke? Now hold on. That's bad for them. They shouldn't do that. It will kill them. So let's raise taxes on cigarettes so it will be more difficult for them and we'll save their life!
That's the mindset of many people including politicians who have the power to increase taxes on 'sin products' like cigarettes, alcohol, and soft drinks.
Sin Tax (Wikipedia)
A Tax to Combat America’s Sugary Diet (New York Times)
Time to crack down on Big Tobacco (CNN)
There are many instances of people deciding something isn't good or good for people and attempt to get it outlawed or taxed. These include same-sex marriage, smoking, abortion, stem-cell research, sugary drinks, and many more. It's not enough that these people don't do it themselves. They want to impose their beliefs on someone else. As long as they aren't hurting anyone, leave them alone. If they want to hurt themselves, that's their choice. As a side note, smokers who do so with kids in the car should be liable, but that's another blog topic.
The most infamous attempt to regulate behaviour was Prohibition which caused large-scale bootlegging and a thriving black market.
Here is one current attempt to forestall sugary drinks that failed. Failure of State Soda Tax Plan Reflects Power of an Antitax Message (New York Times)
UPDATE: The upside of raising taxes on alcohol - fewer deaths, researchers say (LA Times)
UPDATE - More than just the United States: Minimum pricing alcohol plan facing defeat (BBC News)
What if your neighbor does these things? Long hair? No problem. Eat potato chips? No problem. Smoke? Now hold on. That's bad for them. They shouldn't do that. It will kill them. So let's raise taxes on cigarettes so it will be more difficult for them and we'll save their life!
That's the mindset of many people including politicians who have the power to increase taxes on 'sin products' like cigarettes, alcohol, and soft drinks.
Sin Tax (Wikipedia)
A Tax to Combat America’s Sugary Diet (New York Times)
Time to crack down on Big Tobacco (CNN)
There are many instances of people deciding something isn't good or good for people and attempt to get it outlawed or taxed. These include same-sex marriage, smoking, abortion, stem-cell research, sugary drinks, and many more. It's not enough that these people don't do it themselves. They want to impose their beliefs on someone else. As long as they aren't hurting anyone, leave them alone. If they want to hurt themselves, that's their choice. As a side note, smokers who do so with kids in the car should be liable, but that's another blog topic.
The most infamous attempt to regulate behaviour was Prohibition which caused large-scale bootlegging and a thriving black market.
Here is one current attempt to forestall sugary drinks that failed. Failure of State Soda Tax Plan Reflects Power of an Antitax Message (New York Times)
UPDATE: The upside of raising taxes on alcohol - fewer deaths, researchers say (LA Times)
UPDATE - More than just the United States: Minimum pricing alcohol plan facing defeat (BBC News)
Monday, July 12, 2010
Online gambling isn't going away
Online gambling has been around for many years. And trying to regulate what can and can't be done on the internet is a mostly futile attempt. If the U.S. government tries to stop online gambling, the gambling establishments will just take their businesses offshore and the gamblers will still be able to gamble.And, yes, I'm not blind to the fact that some people are addicted to gambling. People can be addicted to anything.
Online gambling: you bet (The Economist)
Monday, June 7, 2010
Ban the burqa?
Belgium is well on it's way to banning the burqa and niqab that many Muslim women wear. And other European countries may follow suit. Short Burqa Article(NPR)
Some issues I have heard in recent years are in France, in 2009, the French President said 'burqas are not welcome in France' because 'we cannot accept that women are prisoners behind a screen'. In 2005, in Florida, a woman's claim that she wants her drivers license photo taken while wearing her burqa was denied by a Florida court.
Women of Muslim faith are required to wear a burqa for religious reasons. Does this mean that her faith trumps law? We DO have a separation of church and state, but we also have laws that prevent people from doing harm, even if religion is involved. Terrorism is cited as the main reason for preventing women from having their faces covered in their photos. Should this be considered on a case by case basis?
What do you think? Should a woman be allowed to wear her burqa for her driver's license? Should she be denied her license if she refuses? Driving IS a privilege, after all, not a right.
An excellent article can be found here: Europe's Burqa Wars
Some issues I have heard in recent years are in France, in 2009, the French President said 'burqas are not welcome in France' because 'we cannot accept that women are prisoners behind a screen'. In 2005, in Florida, a woman's claim that she wants her drivers license photo taken while wearing her burqa was denied by a Florida court.
Women of Muslim faith are required to wear a burqa for religious reasons. Does this mean that her faith trumps law? We DO have a separation of church and state, but we also have laws that prevent people from doing harm, even if religion is involved. Terrorism is cited as the main reason for preventing women from having their faces covered in their photos. Should this be considered on a case by case basis?
What do you think? Should a woman be allowed to wear her burqa for her driver's license? Should she be denied her license if she refuses? Driving IS a privilege, after all, not a right.
An excellent article can be found here: Europe's Burqa Wars
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)






